
I make no apologies for being a Yankees' fan. Nor do I make apologies for dislike of Alex Rodriguez, former Texas Ranger and current Yankee third baseman. I realize he's headed for the Hall of Fame and I know he's won the MVP, been an all-star and won a batting title, blah, blah. That's great when you can be the MVP on a last place team in Texas and hit most of your home runs and get RBIs long after your team falls out of contention. But where has this guy gone that he's really lifted the team and the players around him? Seattle? Maybe. That was before he got his record $252 million contract and became arrogant, aloof, and annoying. Certainly he didn't lift the Texas Rangers though. He hurt them, despite his MVP numbers. And certainly he hasn't lifted the Yankees. He has hurt them. Has he put up good, All-Star numbers with the Yankees? Yes. But he's also caused problems in the locker room and he's faded when his team really needed him to perform. Though it's not something that can be quantified in a tangible manner, I think the New York Yankees will continue underperforming as long as Alex Rodriguez is a member of that team. He's a symbol of everything that is wrong with baseball, and he's certainly not the organization above myself kind of guy that New York is so famous for in its history.....Ruth, Gehrig, Dimaggio, Mantle, Berra, Hunter, Ford, Jackson, Mattingly, Clemens, Martinez, Posada, Brosius, Cone, and of course, Jeter. Those guys are talented just like A-Rod, but they had toughness. The had the intangibles.
One intangible is producing when it really counts. Let's look at A-Rod compared to teammate Derek Jeter (definitely a winner) in playoff games over the past two seasons:
2006 Division Series
(Player) (AB) (Batting Average) (RBIs) (HRs) (On Base%)
Rodriguez 14, .071, 0, 0, .133
Jeter 16, .500, 1, 1, .529
2005 Postseason
(Player) (AB) (Batting Average) (RBIs) (HRs) (On Base%)
Rodriguez 15, .133, 0, 0, n/a
Jeter 21, .333, 5, 2, n/a
Make no mistake about it, statistics can be manipulative and A-Rod had a good 2004 postseason and when the Mariners made the postseason in the 1990s he was good. But here's the highest paid player in major league baseball and also the owner of the richest contract ever, a quarter of a billion dollars, and he can't help you win games when it really matters. On top of that, he is widely known as a polarizing figure in the locker room and has been quoted several times touting his own work ethic as greater than that of his teammates. So, please Santa, for Christmas give Alex Rodriguez to another team.